Compassionate Madison Car Accident Attorneys
Key Takeaways
- Get an insider on your side: Founder Robert Kasieta spent 14 years representing insurance companies, giving his team the knowledge needed to outsmart corporate delay tactics and boost your compensation.
- Know your rights in Wisconsin: State law uses comparative negligence rules, meaning your final payout depends on proving fault. You also have a strict three-year deadline to file an injury claim (or two years for wrongful death).
- Recover full financial losses: The firm builds strong, thorough cases to cover your medical bills, lost wages and long-term suffering from serious injuries like brain trauma or spinal damage.
- Take action quickly: Insurance companies work fast to protect their profits, so call Kasieta Legal Group, LLC at 608-291-9650 today to get an experienced former insurance defense lawyer fighting for you.

A car accident may be one of the most terrifying experiences of your life. The serious injuries you sustain from a car crash may cause significant physical and financial burdens that aren’t easy to overcome. Navigating this overwhelming situation, including managing complex insurance claims and proving negligence, can only add to your stress and worries about the future. At Kasieta Legal Group, LLC, we understand the challenges people face after a car accident. Our experienced Madison car accident attorneys have served personal injury victims in the Madison, Wisconsin, community for over 25 years. We aim to achieve the financial compensation you deserve to cover medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. We care about your injuries and how your accident has affected your life, and we are dedicated to protecting your rights under Wisconsin law.
Let us guide you through your options. Call us at 608-291-9650 or fill out our online form to get started.
Table of Contents
Need A Car Accident Attorney Near You?
Our award winning lawyers have you covered!
Need A Car Accident Attorney Near You?
Our award winning lawyers have you covered!
Why Hire Our Madison Car Accident Attorneys?
Choosing the right legal team after a serious crash can affect what happens next. At Kasieta Legal Group, LLC, our Madison car accident attorneys focus on careful case work and clear communication. We do not push cases toward fast outcomes. We take time to understand your injuries and the changes you now face.
When you work with our firm, you benefit from the following:
- Insurance defense experience: Attorney Robert Kasieta spent 14 years representing insurance companies and gained direct insight into how insurers evaluate claims and prepare defenses.
- Sustained peer recognition: Attorney Kasieta has earned Super Lawyers recognition for 21 years and received consistent acknowledgment from other attorneys over time.
- Trial and pretrial credentials: Attorney Robert Kasieta has taught trial and pretrial advocacy for many years at UW-Madison and holds board certifications in civil trial and pretrial practice.
- Team-based representation: Attorney Kasieta leads a team where attorneys and experienced staff work together on each case without added cost or delay.
- Local courtroom experience: Attorney Kasieta has practiced in the Madison area for decades and understands local courts and procedures.
These strengths help our team prepare car accident cases with focus and a clear view of how insurers respond.
How To Prove Fault In A Wisconsin Motor Vehicle Accident?
To prove fault in a Wisconsin motor vehicle accident, you generally must establish that the other driver acted negligently and that the driver’s negligence caused the accident and your resulting injuries or losses. Wisconsin’s modified comparative negligence laws also consider your own share of fault when determining how much compensation you may recover.
Key Elements To Prove Negligence
To establish negligence after a car accident, you generally need to show:
- Duty of care: Drivers have a duty to use reasonable care when operating a vehicle around others on the road.
- Breach of duty: The other driver failed to use reasonable care, such as by speeding, driving while distracted, failing to yield or otherwise acting unsafely.
- Causation: The driver’s negligent conduct caused or contributed to the accident and your injuries.
- Harm: You suffered actual losses because of the accident, such as medical expenses, lost wages, physical pain or other damages.
Determining fault can require more than looking at which vehicle struck the other. The circumstances leading up to the crash can matter, including traffic conditions, vehicle movements, roadway conditions, visibility and the actions of each driver.
Evidence To Collect
Evidence from the accident can help establish what happened and who was responsible. Depending on the circumstances, useful evidence may include:
- Police reports: A police report can document the location of the crash, the drivers involved and information gathered by responding officers.
- Photos and videos: Photos of vehicle damage, road conditions, traffic signs, lane markings and visible injuries can help document the scene.
- Witness information: Names and contact information for people who saw the crash may provide independent accounts of what happened.
- Medical records: Medical records can document your injuries, treatment and the connection between the accident and your condition.
- Vehicle damage: Damage to the vehicles can help show how the collision occurred and where the impact took place.
- Traffic or surveillance video: Available video may show the crash or what happened immediately before it.
- Other records: In some cases, cellphone records, vehicle data or other documentation may provide additional evidence about a driver’s conduct.
Collecting evidence early can matter. Photos, video footage and witness memories may become harder to obtain as time passes.
Wisconsin’s Comparative Negligence Rule
Under Wisconsin law, your recovery can be reduced if you share responsibility for a car accident. You can still recover damages when you are 50% or less at fault, but your award is reduced by your share of fault. If your share of fault exceeds 50%, you generally cannot recover damages.
For example, imagine a driver makes an unsafe left turn at an intersection and collides with an oncoming vehicle. The oncoming driver was traveling above the speed limit, which also contributed to the crash. If the driver making the turn is found 70% at fault and the other driver 30% at fault, the injured driver can still seek compensation, but the award would be reduced by 30%.
Insurance companies may try to assign some of the blame to you to reduce the amount they pay. Evidence showing how the accident happened can help establish each driver’s share of fault.
“Under Wisconsin’s comparative fault rule, insurance companies constantly try to shift even 10% or 20% of the blame onto the injured driver to reduce their payout. My advice to accident victims is simple: never give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurer until you have spoken with an attorney who understands how fault is legally assigned in Dane County.”
— Robert J. Kasieta, Founder & Certified Civil Trial Specialist
What Are The Common Types Of Car Accidents?
Car accidents can happen in many different ways. Some of the most common types of motor vehicle accidents include:
- Single-passenger vehicles
- Semi trucks and commercial vehicles
- Single-passenger vehicle or truck collisions with a motorcycle
- Motor vehicle collisions with bicycles
- Motor vehicle crashes involving pedestrians
- Collisions with rideshare vehicles such as Uber or Lyft cars
- Roundabout accidents
- Rear-end accidents
- Multivehicle accidents
- T-bone accidents
- Sideswipe accidents
- Head-on collisions
- Rollover accidents
- Intersection accidents
- Hit-and-run accidents
Each type of crash can raise different questions about how the accident happened, who was responsible and what evidence may help establish fault. The location of the crash, the vehicles involved and the circumstances leading up to the collision can all affect a personal injury claim.
In Madison, local road conditions can also shape the circumstances of a crash. The Beltline (US Highway 12/18), for example, carries heavy traffic and can involve high-speed rear-end and lane-merge crashes. Madison’s many roundabouts can also create unique situations where drivers must manage speed, yielding and lane position.
If another driver’s negligence caused your accident, a Madison car accident attorney can help you understand your legal options and pursue compensation for your injuries and losses.
Wisconsin Negligence Law: Insights From Attorney Robert Kasieta
Understanding Wisconsin negligence law is an important part of pursuing a car accident claim. Attorney Robert Kasieta shared his insights in this article on how negligence is established, how fault is assigned and how comparative negligence can affect compensation.
With more than 40 years of legal experience, Robert brings firsthand knowledge of how Wisconsin negligence laws apply to personal injury cases.
What Are The Common Causes Of Car Accidents In Wisconsin?
Even the most cautious drivers can end up in accidents due to other drivers’ negligence. Some of the most common causes of car accidents in Madison and throughout Wisconsin include:
- Speeding: Drivers who drive well over the speed limit can put everyone on the road at risk of an accident. Speeding reduces a driver’s ability to maintain control of their car, which can lead to a serious accident.
- Distracted driving: Texting, talking on the phone or with other passengers, using GPS or even fiddling with the radio are all actions that take a driver’s mind off the act of driving. When someone is distracted, they’re not paying attention to other drivers around them, increasing the risk of an accident.
- Drunk or impaired driving: Driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs reduces a driver’s ability to react in time to dangers on the road.
- Drowsy driving: Similarly, driving while fatigued or drowsy can impact a driver’s ability to make sound decisions and stay in control of their vehicle.
Other factors, like poor road or weather conditions, can also play a role in causing a serious car accident. Any of these causes can lead to many types of accidents, including T-bone accidents, rear-end accidents, sideswipe accidents or rollover accidents. No matter the reason, if the other driver’s negligence caused your crash, you are entitled to seek compensation.
What Are Common Car Accident Injuries?
Car accidents can cause injuries that affect daily life long after the crash. Some injuries require ongoing care or limit routine activities. Serious injuries often seen in car accident cases include the following:
- Spinal injuries: Damage to the spine can affect movement or sensation and may require long-term medical care, including treatment addressed in spinal injury cases.
- Traumatic brain injuries: Head trauma can cause changes in thinking, mood or physical function linked to traumatic brain injuries.
- Broken bones: Fractures often require surgery, physical therapy and time away from work or daily tasks.
- Internal injuries: Organ damage or internal bleeding can create serious health risks even when symptoms appear later.
Knowing the type and extent of an injury helps clarify the care and records that may matter in a claim.
What Should You Do After A Madison Car Accident?
A car accident can leave you feeling shocked and confused. It’s normal to be lost about what to do in the immediate aftermath of a crash, especially if you’ve never been in one before. The following steps can help you stay safe and maintain control of a scary situation:
- Get to safety: The first thing you must do after an accident is get to safety. If you’re able to move from your car, it’s best to get to the side of the road or somewhere out of traffic as soon as possible.
- Call the police: It’s important to report the accident to the police. They can provide you with a police report afterward, which can help when pursuing a claim. They can also send for an ambulance if there are any injuries.
- Collect information: Get the other driver’s contact, license and insurance information. If there are any witnesses to the accident, you should also collect their contact information.
- Document the scene: Take photo or video evidence of the accident scene, the damage to your car and any immediate injuries to build a strong personal injury case.
- Get medical care: As soon as you’re able, it’s crucial to visit a doctor. Some car accident injuries aren’t immediately apparent after a crash. A doctor can examine you properly and determine if you need further treatment.
- Contact an attorney: Working with a Madison car accident lawyer can help you prepare a solid personal injury case against the other driver’s insurance company. Our lawyer can negotiate with insurance companies and seek fair compensation.
Remembering these steps is sure to provide you with clarity and focus after a serious car accident.
How Partial Fault Can Affect Your Car Accident Claim
Being partially at fault does not necessarily prevent you from recovering compensation. Under Wisconsin law, your damages may be reduced by your percentage of fault, but you generally cannot recover if you are more than 50% at fault.
Insurance companies may try to shift blame to an injured driver. Our attorneys can review the evidence and challenge an unfair assignment of fault.
More Than $50 Million Recovered In Settlements And Verdicts
Kasieta Legal Group, LLC, has successfully recovered more than $50 million in settlements and verdicts for clients. While past results do not guarantee or predict the outcome of any future case, they demonstrate the experience our Madison car accident attorneys have in handling serious motor vehicle injury claims. Some representative results include:
- $800,000 Settlement – Rear-End Collision: Settlement obtained for an 83- and 84-year-old couple who were rear-ended at highway speeds.
- $750,000 Settlement – Biker vs. Motorist Collision: Settlement obtained for a biker and his spouse who were hit by a motorist who was transporting cattle.
- $600,000 Settlement – T-Bone Collision: Settlement obtained for a passenger of a vehicle involved in a T-bone collision.
These results reflect our commitment to building strong cases for clients who have suffered serious injuries in motor vehicle accidents.
What You Can Expect When Working With Our Firm
At Kasieta Legal Group, LLC, you get experienced legal representation with the personal attention of a local firm. Our attorneys and staff work together to understand your case, keep you informed and pursue the compensation you deserve.
- Insurance defense experience: Founder Robert Kasieta spent 14 years representing insurance companies, giving our team insight into how insurers evaluate and defend injury claims.
- A team approach: Our attorneys and experienced staff work together on your case, bringing different perspectives and decades of combined experience.
- Personal attention: We take the time to understand how your accident has affected your health, work and daily life.
- Clear communication: We keep you informed about your case and make it easy to ask questions when concerns arise.
- Trial experience: Our attorneys have extensive experience handling complex personal injury cases and preparing cases for trial when necessary.
That combination of experience and personal attention is central to how we represent clients after serious accidents. Managing Attorney Noah Relles explains what that team approach means for clients:
“A serious crash on the Beltline or University Avenue isn’t just about fixing a car – it’s about covering years of medical care, missed work, and physical rehabilitation. Our firm takes a team approach to every case so our clients get the combined weight of 90-plus years of local trial experience without paying anything out of pocket unless we recover compensation.”
— Noah Relles, Managing Attorney
Representing Accident Victims Throughout Madison
Kasieta Legal Group, LLC, is located on the western side of Madison, the capital city of Wisconsin. We are close to a variety of local resources that may help you after an accident, including:
- Dane County Courthouse (12 miles): 215 S Hamilton Street, 608-266-4311
- Madison Municipal Court (12 miles): 210 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd #203, 608-264-9282
- UW Health University Hospital (6 miles): 600 Highland Avenue, 608-263-6400
- UnityPoint Health – Meriter Hospital (6 miles): 202 S Park Street, 608-417-6000
- SSM Health St. Mary’s Hospital – Madison (9 miles): 700 S Brooks Street, 608-251-6100

If you need assistance after an accident, we can help. Call our Madison car accident attorneys at 608-291-9650 to learn what steps to take next.
Answering Your Frequently Asked Questions About Motor Vehicle Accidents
If you have been injured in a car accident, we understand that you probably have a lot of questions. Here, our personal injury lawyers answer a few of the frequently asked questions.
How long do I have to file a lawsuit for a car accident in Wisconsin?
Where the accident results in a death, the statute of limitations is two years from the date of the accident. Generally, the statute of limitations for car crash cases is three years. But the rules vary depending on the circumstances.
Should I accept the insurance company’s offer for a settlement?
You should never accept an offer to settle your accident injury claims without the counsel and advice of an experienced personal injury lawyer. Our founding attorney, Robert Kasieta, worked as an insurance defense attorney prior to representing accident victims to protect their rights. He understands and can explain the tactics that insurance companies practice, including bad faith delay, unfair reliance on the injured person’s preexisting conditions and asserting defenses that simply prolong the process and wear out the injured person.
What kind of damages can I get in a personal injury lawsuit for a motor vehicle accident?
In any personal injury case, you can seek economic and noneconomic damages such as medical expenses, lost wages, and even emotional pain and suffering. Our Madison car accident attorneys at Kasieta Legal Group, LLC, can assess the facts of your specific case and provide a better understanding of the types of damages that might be available in your case.
What if I can’t afford medical treatment right now, or my health insurance refuses to pay?
You should not delay necessary medical treatment because you are worried about the cost. There may be options for addressing accident-related medical expenses while your injury claim is pending.
We understand the financial stress that follows a serious accident. Clients often worry about accumulating medical bills, paying out of pocket or having their health insurance deny coverage for crash-related treatment. Our team can help you understand your options, review medical billing concerns and address questions involving providers and insurance companies. You do not have to navigate these issues alone.
Keep copies of your medical bills, insurance correspondence and treatment records. These documents can help your legal team understand the expenses associated with your injuries.
What happens if I had a preexisting medical condition before the crash?
A preexisting condition does not automatically prevent you from recovering compensation. Your medical records can help show whether the crash caused a new injury or worsened an existing condition.
Insurance companies may use your prior medical history to challenge your claim. Robert Kasieta’s 14 years of experience representing insurers gives the firm insight into how these arguments are commonly handled.
“Insurance adjusters are not in the business of paying full value on claims – their goal is to close files quickly and cheaply. Having spent 14 years on the insurance defense side, I know the exact evaluation formulas and delay tactics they use. We build our cases from day one to neutralize those strategies before the adjuster can even deploy them.”
— Robert J. Kasieta, Founder & Certified Civil Trial Specialist
Injured In A Car Crash? Speak With Our Experienced Madison Car Accident Attorneys.
If you or a loved one has been injured in a Madison car accident, you may be entitled to compensation. Our car accident lawyers have years of experience in handling complex accident cases with the care and attention to detail each client deserves. We proudly represent people throughout Madison who have been injured by a negligent driver. Call our firm at 608-291-9650 today to discuss your case or send us an email online.
Our office is conveniently located:
559 D'Onofrio Drive
Suite 222
Madison, WI 53719
Super Lawyers is an attorney rating program that identifies lawyers through a multi-step selection process. That process considers peer nominations, independent research and professional evaluations. The recognition referenced here is not endorsed or approved by the Supreme Court of Wisconsin.

